Another challenge for my military analysts in the blogosphere
Bookworm at Bookworm Room on Aug 25 2007 at 5:03 pm | Filed under: Feature Article, Linkfest
The New York Times has again thrust before me food for thought — and food that I haven’t seen addressed in the major conservative blogs. Again, it involves military personnel criticizing the war effort. The trigger article is a May 2007 opinion piece in the Armed Forces Journal in which Lt. Col. Paul Yingling strongly criticizes the role of generals in the Iraq War. His opening paragraphs spell out his premise, which he develops at length in the article itself:
For the second time in a generation, the United States faces the prospect of defeat at the hands of an insurgency. In April 1975, the U.S. fled the Republic of Vietnam, abandoning our allies to their fate at the hands of North Vietnamese communists. In 2007, Iraq’s grave and deteriorating condition offers diminishing hope for an American victory and portends risk of an even wider and more destructive regional war.
These debacles are not attributable to individual failures, but rather to a crisis in an entire institution: America’s general officer corps. America’s generals have failed to prepare our armed forces for war and advise civilian authorities on the application of force to achieve the aims of policy. The argument that follows consists of three elements. First, generals have a responsibility to society to provide policymakers with a correct estimate of strategic probabilities. Second, America’s generals in Vietnam and Iraq failed to perform this responsibility. Third, remedying the crisis in American generalship requires the intervention of Congress.
It’s not an anti-War article. It is a complaint about the military leadership guiding the war effort. That’s certainly a valid issue during a time of war. Whether we should have gone into Iraq is one for the historians to debate. What’s real and important right now is the fact that we are in Iraq and we need to win. Yingling says that our bureaucratic generalship, a stodgy collection of people who don’t know whether they’re supposed to lead or follow, is putting the American effort at risk. Of course, turning to Congress for help, the same Congress with an 18% popularity rating — reflecting America’s understanding of its bungling incompetency and partisan blinders — is probably not the real answer.
In July 2007, Lt. Col. John Mauk came back with a rebuttal. Here’s his premise, which sounds actually more factual, reasonable, and do-able than Yingling’s grand blame and high falutin’ plans to remake the American military in the middle of a war:
As a career Army officer, I found many elements of Lt. Col. Paul Yingling’s assessment of our general officers’ leadership to ring true, but his use of history and facts are selective, his expectations of Congress as a solution are naive and his stance a bit self-righteous. This rebuttal does not excuse those few generals who are culpable in failing to stand up to a secretary of defense and the U.S. administrator in Iraq, but Yingling’s scathing assessment doesn’t apply to the great majority of our generals.
Although it is reasonable to debate a crisis of leadership and moral conviction among our general officers, let’s put Yingling’s characterization in perspective. His assertion that our generals failed to plan and have neglected their strategic role is a myopic view and the product of selective memory. Our generals are exceptionally well-educated in the profession of arms by any standard. They are students of history and products of the same professional education system that produced Yingling and me.
And there the whole issue might have stopped, as far as I was concerned, if Mr. Bookworm, one of the New York Times‘ most faithful readers, hadn’t directed me to this lengthy Sunday Times article entitled Challenging the Generals. Fred Kaplan’s writing makes for interesting reading, but I really can’t tell if it makes a new argument different from any other that could apply to military leadership in a long war: you make mistakes in the beginning as you try to figure out what works best; 20/20 hindsight is can be used to effect future change, but can be dangerously used to assign blame that deflects attention from the task at hand; mid-level officers, like mid-level management in any company, like some of the leadership people and dislike others; large institutions change slowly; etc. The description of Lt. Col. Yingling makes it hard to tell if he’s a malcontent, someone who pompously always knows best, or a Cassandra, a visionary resolutely ignored by people who will go down to their deaths defending the bad old ways.
I have the feeling that, as Phibian pointed out regarding the New York Times‘ most recent attack on the military’s approach to war, in an institution as huge as the American military, there are always going to be conflicting viewpoints; happy people; unhappy people; ideas people; bullheaded, ignorant people, etc. What most troops do is what troops have always done: they muddle along, try to keep their balance, and hope for brilliant leadership from on high. And, with all due respect to the vast majority of humans in the world, few of us are brilliant, so the last may be a faint hope.
By the way, is it just me or is it really true that, having reluctantly acknowledged that the Surge is not a disaster, the Times’ new approach is to slam the military directly?
Just remember, George often found himself a very maligned general, too.
Trackposted to Outside the Beltway, The Pink Flamingo, The Virtuous Republic, Rosemary’s Thoughts, Faultline USA, Big Dog’s Weblog, , and Walls of the City, thanks to Linkfest Haven Deluxe.
[Discuss This Topic With Bookworm at Bookworm Room]
military, Lt. Col. Paul Yingling, Iraq War, Vietnam
Beyond batteries Storing power in a sheet of paper…
The nanoengineered battery is lightweight, ultra thin, completely flexible, and geared toward meeting the trickiest design and energy requirements of tomorrowÂ’s gadgets…
Joe Kaufman of Americans Against Hate – on H…
Joe Kaufman, Americans Against Hate and CAIR Watch, appears on Hannity Colmes to discuss the NYC madrassa and the upcoming NYC islamist day parade. Colmes plays the typical dhimmi.Trackposted to Outside the Beltway, Blog @ MoreWhat.com, Perri Nelson’s…
premature … somethingoranother…
So I have a small confession to make. I was going to be a good little boy, and postpone any major firearm-related purchases until Tuesday’s National Exercise Your Rights Day – after all, it would make the largest impact then…….
Ah, sweet Saturday; OTB…
What have I accomplished today? Let’s see…I went through emails, I worked on my open trackbacks, I got a new mouse that had a cord that was too short (actually, my brother got it for me because I don’t leave the apartment, but that’s a whole di …..
[...] Blog @ MoreWhat.com, The Random Yak, Nanotechnology Today, DeMediacratic Nation, Adam’s Blog, Webloggin, Phastidio.net, The Bullwinkle Blog, Conservative Cat, Conservative Thoughts, Diary of the Mad [...]
Women who smell bad…
Once you bathe them all women of the same race smell the same. …
The Knucklehead of the Day award…
Today’s winner is Angel Cruz….
Immigration Activists Protest Deportation of Arellano…
According to the article from Newstext hundreds of Immigration activists marched in Los Angeles yesterday in order to show solidarity with Elvira Arellano, the woman that was deported last week after having hidden in a Chicago church for a year….
Drop Dead or much to do about nothing?…
Will the DNC’s decision anger Florida voters or make little difference? I’m saying the later….
[...] The Random Yak, Nanotechnology Today, DeMediacratic Nation, Nuke’s News & Views, Webloggin, Phastidio.net, The Bullwinkle Blog, , Conservative Cat, Diary of the Mad Pigeon, Faultline USA, [...]
[...] Thyself, Big Dog’s Weblog, Shadowscope, Nuke’s News & Views, Blue Star Chronicles, Webloggin, Leaning Straight Up, and Phastidio.net, thanks to Linkfest Haven [...]
[...] Blog @ MoreWhat.com, The Random Yak, Nanotechnology Today, DeMediacratic Nation, Adam’s Blog, Webloggin, Phastidio.net, The Bullwinkle Blog, , Conservative Cat, Diary of the Mad Pigeon, Allie Is Wired, [...]
Labor Safety to Labor Unions, Politics Hurt Oversight…
……
The Geopolitics of Conservation…
Allow me to paraphrase a Brazilian officer: “to you the Amazon’s a rainforest. To us it’s a jungle, and we’ll cut it down if we want to.”…
Hangings, Executions and other good stuff…
Iran has hanged up to 30 people in the past month amid a clampdown prompted by alleged U.S.-backed plots to topple the regime, while the EU urges Texas to end executions. Iran: (here via here) Many executions have been carried…
When Fake News is Presented as Truth by the Main S…
Its a mystery to me as to why the Old Media insists on reporting the amateurish propaganda that comes out of the middle east while ignoring reporting any news stories that promote the best interest of the United States. Its a very strange phenomena t…..
Linkfesting…
Trackposted to …
Americans, Iraqis interact at historical monument…
It has been more than 10 years since any Iraqi native has been allowed to visit the Ziggurat of Ur, which is the most dominant landmark on Ali Base, because during the reign of Suddam Hussein the installation was used by the Iraqi army….
Owen Wilson Hospitalized Following Possible Suicid…
The National Enquirer later revealed that he had been found by a family member after he had sliced his left wrist and taken an undetermined number of pills. His condition was listed as very serious and his prognosis grim. He has sense been upgraded a…..
Encrypted, Game-Theoretic Methodologies…
Linear-time modalities and replication have garnered tremendous interest from both researchers and computational biologists in the last several years. In fact, few mathematicians would disagree with the emulation of digital-to-analog converters….
More cartoon “Dhimmitude”: Newspapers refuse to print Opus cartoon Mocking Islam…
I have avoided the use of this term in the past as it is pejorative and far too convenient for my tastes.
But more and more, the ass kissing of Muslim hyper-sensitivity has been irking me, so I see no reason to continue ignoring it for what it is.
…
9th Circus Court Strikes another blow to those darn Christians…
Darn those Christian kids, expecting they can assemble and associate like the chess club or the Anime Club.
What were they thinking? Were they expecting some constitutional protection or something?
Leave it to the 9th Circuit Circus Cou…
The Knuckleheads of the Day award…
Today’s winners are the Makkal Osai newspaper and Malaysia’s Internal Security Ministry….